What if we say the ‘group believes’ what the majority of the group believes? - Problem: majorities are not consistent over multiple beliefs IF the beliefs are logically connected. - 51% of people believe \(P\), 51% believe \(Q\), 1% believe \(P\land Q\). - Under this proposal, the majority has inconsistent beliefs (and therefore believes everything) - Real example: - German politicians voted on the the three propositions: - Should Berlin or Bohn be the capital? - Should the parliament be in Berlin or Bohn? - Should the capital be where parliament is?